Bilawal's statement on constitutional amendment could lead to 'disqualification', says Sanaullah

Adviser to the Prime Minister on Political Affairs Rana Sanaullah on Tuesday said PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari's remarks about the passage of the 27th Constitutional Amendment under pressure could amount to grounds for disqualification, questioning whether the PPP leader was suggesting that he had cast his vote under someone's influence.

His remarks came hours after Bilawal, speaking at the Karachi Press Club, said the 27th Amendment had been passed without political consensus or mutual agreement and had effectively been "imposed through force".

He argued that, as a result, the judiciary no longer enjoyed the confidence of all sections of Pakistani society.

Speaking on a local television programme, Capital Talk, Sanaullah said the PPP was not only part of the coalition government and held key positions in it but had also participated in every stage of the legislative process, including the 26th and 27th amendments.

"They were fully involved in the 26th Amendment. For the 27th Amendment, they ensured that every single vote was accounted for, and now they are calling it brute force," he said.

He questioned whether Bilawal's statement that he had cast his vote himself implied that he had done so under someone's influence.

"If a political party makes such a claim about itself, even a year later — or on the very same day — saying that it cast its vote to amend the Constitution under someone's influence or pressure, I believe that amounts to disqualification," Sanaullah said.

He advised Bilawal to listen to and review his speech, saying the remarks he had made were actually going against him.

Asked by the programme's anchor whether the statement could expose Bilawal to the risk of disqualification, Sanaullah said that if a party leader claimed to have cast his vote under someone's influence or pressure rather than exercising his own free will, it raised serious questions.

Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari on Tuesday called for a "political reset" to restore confidence in the country's institutions, saying the political system had not collapsed on its own but had been deliberately dismantled.

Speaking at the Karachi Press Club, the PPP scion said, "The system needs a reset, but it must be a political reset,” while emphasising that politicians, as elected representatives of the people, must participate in the process so that the country's core issues could be resolved.

“The system did not collapse on its own; it was made to collapse. I am also responsible for this. Every person makes mistakes, and there comes a time when those mistakes must be corrected,” Bilawal stated during the press conference

He regretted that political forces appeared more focused on creating divisions than addressing the pressing problems confronting the people.

“The politicians are talking about everything except the issues faced by the people,” he said, stressing the need to remind elected representatives of the responsibilities entrusted to them.

Bilawal observed that although there was widespread recognition that the system had collapsed, little attention was being paid to understanding the reasons behind its failure. He maintained that any meaningful effort to reform the system must involve political stakeholders, particularly elected representatives, rather than being pursued without their participation.

Bilawal said "restoring public confidence" was the first prerequisite for a political reset.

Referring to the country's key institutions, he said, “Whether it is the parliament, election commission, judiciary or the media, these institutions were made to collapse."

He stressed the need for a comprehensive discussion on institutional weaknesses and corrective measures

Turning to the economic woes faced by commoners, Bilawal said inflation and economic deprivation in the present era were unprecedented.

“I have never witnessed an economic crisis of this magnitude before. I am deeply concerned about what will happen to the poor and the working class of society after witnessing the alarming pace at which inflation is rising.”

He said he was wary that people were finding it difficult to pay their electricity and transportation costs.

The PPP stalwart expressed concern about the ability of low-income families, salaried households and working-class communities to cope with worsening economic conditions.

Talking about the freedom of the press, Bilawal said it was inevitable to ensure true freedom across all sections of society and therefore the PPP was ready to take criticism of laws restricting this freedom onto the floor of the assembly.

Speaking on the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA), Bilawal acknowledged concerns about its impact on media freedom and the need for a mechanism to address misinformation and fake news. He called for the establishment of a Media Complaints Commission, suggesting that a commission comprising representatives of the Sindh government and the Press Club should be formed to deal with media-related complaints.

Moving on to parliament as a key pillar of the state, Bilawal rebuked the government for questioning opposition leaders' allegiance, saying, “The most patriotic job in any parliament is the job of the opposition.”

There should be freedom of expression inside the parliament, he added

“If we truly wish to reset the system, the change should start from the parliament, which currently witnesses opposition leaders observing a complete lack of confidence, and they have genuine reasons for it.”

“We should restore the confidence of the opposition in the government.”

Citing the example of Maulana Fazlur Rehman, the PPP scion said his criticism of the government was met with action against him through NAB and the anti-encroachment drive

“They should respond to his questions even if they don’t like it,” he suggested to the government, adding that it is Fazl’s responsibility as one of the opposition leaders to take to task the government on issues where he differs with them.

He questioned as to why the government suddenly realised that his residence might include encroached space after he delivered a speech against them.

“To understand Maulana Fazlur Rehman's role, look at the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM). If he had not played his role, you would not be sitting in your current position.”

He also took a jab at the government for ignoring the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) as a political power.

“Alongside Maulana [Fazl], you must acknowledge the presence of PTI, the party of Imran Khan, by naming it. You have to restore their confidence as well.”  

“The country cannot be managed without recognising their political stake.”

Speaking about Imran and his party, Bilawal also said that he considered the former prime minister a political prisoner and believed the party was facing political victimisation. In the same breath, he noted that some of the difficulties currently confronting the PTI were also the result of its political navigation and mistakes.

Citing the geopolitical tensions, including war with India and Afghanistan as well as the ongoing US-Iran conflict, he stated that Pakistan was already in distress and in such a condition, it was extremely important to make sure that “the house was in order”.

He maintained that political reconciliation was essential for the functioning of the parliamentary system and for addressing the problems facing ordinary Pakistanis

Speaking to the media, the PPP leader said that, in his opinion, rigging took place in every era and since, for the first time, both the government and the opposition are openly alleging electoral rigging, the issue should be addressed once and for all.

“Electoral rigging must also be addressed as part of the reset so that an environment conducive to the next elections can be created. Through this process, we can also restore the confidence of the PTI and other opposition parties,” he outlined in his speech.

In his remarks, the PPP leader further said, “If we genuinely want to reset the system, at the very least, political victimisation must stop.”

Bilawal warned the government against using NAB as a tool to stifle dissent

“The media must be free, and members of Parliament must be able to work independently. The fear that delivering a speech or signing a bill could result in an NAB case must come to an end. Pakistan should not have any political prisoners,” he added.

“Today or tomorrow, you will have to free all the political prisoners.”

Openly outlining the persecution faced by the PTI, the PPP chairman said it was unfair to the party that their electioneering symbol was taken away and other measures were employed to trick the people during voting. Nevertheless, he noted that the people conveyed their verdict and chose PTI as their representative in the system.

He said that the people cannot be cheated.

“The government stole the reserved seats from the opposition and then brought about two constitutional amendments through it and is now planning a third.”

He asked the government to return the rightful reserved seats of the opposition as a gesture of good will.

Bilawal urged the government to revive political dialogue and end governor’s rule, saying that it cannot be continued forever.

Noting that a majority of PTI leaders were interested in battling terrorism and negotiating with the government, Bilawal suggested that the ruling elite must approach the opposition once again to discuss matters of public concern and restore their confidence.

He also said dialogue should resume from where it had been discontinued, stressing that political opponents should not be excluded from the government but brought into the decision-making process.

Observing that terrorism remained a serious challenge in the country, he emphasised that political engagement was necessary to address the security threat and if the PTI was ready to tackle the issue with support of the centre, it should be encouraged.

The PPP chairman stressed that democracy could not function without public confidence in the election commission, warning that elections would become a waste of public money if the institution lacked credibility.

He also criticised what he described as selective accountability, saying corruption remained a fundamental problem in Pakistan but there appeared to be little genuine interest in addressing it.

He alleged that the NAB was being used as a political weapon, arguing that accountability had become dependent on political affiliations rather than the seriousness of alleged wrongdoing.

He questioned the tendency to focus exclusively on politicians when discussing corruption, pointing out that government officials, secretaries and other relevant authorities were also involved in administrative and decision-making processes.

"Are politicians the only people who commit corruption?" he asked, arguing that no politician could accomplish anything without the involvement of relevant government officials.

He further questioned the legitimacy of a judicial system in which the government had confidence, but the opposition did not, saying institutions must enjoy broader political and public trust.

Bilawal maintained that the system had not collapsed on its own but had been deliberately weakened.

Comparing the constitutional consensus surrounding the 1973 Constitution with the passage of the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, he said every political party had supported the 1973 Constitution, while extensive efforts had been made to secure agreement on the 26th Amendment by keeping the opposition involved.

However, he said the 27th Amendment had been passed without political consensus or mutual agreement and had effectively been imposed through force. As a consequence, he argued, the judiciary no longer enjoyed the confidence of all sections of Pakistani society.

Bilawal called for consultations with the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), the judiciary and the legal community before any further constitutional amendment was introduced. He said judges themselves must have confidence in the process before constitutional changes are brought forward.

PPP chairman voices conditional support for government, reservations regarding new provinces

While stressing the need for a political consensus for the proposed political reset, Bilawal appeared critical of the lack of coordination within the ruling coalition.

He also assailed the government for avoiding critical parliamentary debates.

“Why debates were being deliberately created around matters that should be discussed within Parliament, particularly when federal ministers were involved in publicly challenging the government's own position,” he said, hinting at the discussion around new provinces.

The PPP chairman said Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif should have authority over his ministers, warning that the system could not function effectively if ministers undermined their own head of government.

Criticising the attempts to push decisions through the back door, Bilawal said Pakistan had already witnessed the damaging consequences of such approaches.

On proposals to divide Sindh, Bilawal said the PPP supported the establishment of new provinces in accordance with the wishes of the people. However, he categorically rejected any attempt to divide Sindh through force or unconstitutional means.

“Forcibly dividing the province could lead to serious ethnic and political violence, particularly in Karachi,” he warned.

He also turned down proposals for a referendum on the issue, arguing that referendums had historically not been used for democratic purposes in Pakistan and that the proposed approach was unconstitutional.

Referring to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi and his calls for the creation of new units, Bilawal said he was unaware of his intentions and questioned why the constitutional and legal process had not been initiated if there was genuine interest in establishing a new province.

He pointed out that the PPP had representation in the relevant constitutional and parliamentary forums and had not been approached on the matter

Bilawal linked the debate over new provinces to the broader question of provincial autonomy, particularly the 18th Constitutional Amendment and the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award. He said discussions about these constitutional arrangements were meaningful only in the context of an existing provincial structure.

He also reprimanded the federal government for its failure to fully implement the NFC Award.

“The federal government cuts into the financial resources of provinces and then questions their inability to provide adequate infrastructure and municipal services,” he alleged during the press conference.

Bilawal said the federal government must explain why provincial resources were not being spent on the people, adding that no financial formula could exclude Karachi from Sindh's share.

He also said the PPP had invited the PM Shehbaz to visit Sindh and proposed that federal Cabinet meetings be held in every province to improve coordination and address local concerns.

Speaking about mineral wealth, the PPP chairman said the resource fell entirely within provincial jurisdiction.

Turning to Balochistan, Bilawal said terrorism had reached alarming levels but argued that the underlying causes also included poverty, inflation and unemployment. He expressed concern over the suspension of trade with Iran and Afghanistan, saying the disruption had further intensified economic difficulties for the people of the province.

“Security challenges cannot be addressed in isolation from the economic conditions affecting ordinary citizens,” he explained.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post