Judges are ‘independent and yet dependent’: Justice Mansoor

“We are independent, yet we are also dependent on others at the same time,” observed Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah with a smile on his face while rising for the day after attending tax-related cases in the Supreme Court on Friday.
The observation came when the judges were retiring for a short break during court proceedings, but no usher (“Farishtai” in local parlance), was present in Courtroom No 5. The two-judge bench consisted of Justice Mansoor Ali Shah and Justice Yahya Afridi.
The usher helps judges don or doff their black gowns and pull their chairs to let the judges sit comfortably before the commencement of a hearing or rise after the day’s proceedings and open or close the doors behind the bench to let the judges step outside.
But on Friday the attendants were not inside the room when the case was being heard. Subsequently Justice Shah and Justice Afridi turned to see behind their chairs, but found no attendant in sight.
A court associate rushed outside to call the attendants, but by the time one of them entered the room, the judges were already on their feet and looking towards lawyers, who too were waiting for the doors to be opened.
And when the attendant tried to open the door, he found out that he was not tall enough to enable his hands reach the bolt. However, another court staffer, standing beside the attendant, opened the door.
“We are independent. Yet we are dependent on others at the same time,” quipped Justice Shah while leaving the court.
“It’s a tradition indicative of the aura and dignity of the judicature at the highest level,” commented counsel Muhammad Akram Sheikh.
This practice is strictly in accordance with colonial tradition, but it is not practised in US courts as Americans tend to shun pomp and ceremony, he observed.
“Unlike our system, in the US judges even sit with members of the bar,” Akram Sheikh said. “Our courtrooms have taken Britain as their model. There the first three lines are reserved for the Queen’s Counsel (QC) and no client can sit on them. These lawyers also take precedence during court proceedings.”
In the United States, they have even brought about a fundamental change in the Supreme Court bench by doing away with the custom of having an elevated floor for judges and a lower one for lawyers.
There, he said, judges and lawyers communicate with each other sitting across the table.
“I have not found such formalities in Canada or Australia, but it does not mean that judges have no respect in those countries,” Akram Sheikh said.
Another senior lawyer said the practice of attendants pulling chairs for judges to sit or rise was “a reminder of a colonial era now long dead”.

COMMENTS

Name

Accident Accountability Accounts Adventure Afghanistan Agent Agriculture AID Aircraft Airline Airlines Airport Animals Appeal Arabs Archaeology Army Arrest Arson Art & Craft Article Assassination Assistance automobile Aviation Award Azadi March Bangladesh Banks belief Biometric birds Blast Blogger Brick Kiln Budget Bullion Bureaucracy BUSINESS Business Women Calamity Canteen Capsize Cargo case celebration Celebrity charity Child Labour Child trafficking Chinese Christian Christianity civic Civil Society Clash Cleanliness Clerics Climate Coal-mine collapse Collision Commerce Commission Communication Company Condemnation Conflict Corpses corridore Corruption Court CPEC crash Cricket Crime crimes Culprit culture currency Custodial Death Cyber crime Death Penalty Deaths Defamation Defence Department Deportees Derailment Detention Devastation Development Development And Industry Devotees Devotion Diplomacy Diplomat disaster Displaced Dispute drug traffickers Drugs e-Rozgar Earthquake Economy Education Election Electricity Embassy Embezzlement Employment Encroachment Energy Enmity Entertainment Environment Eveteaser Excavation Execution exhibition Expert Explosion export Extremism Facility Family Famine Fashion felciation festival Fighermen Finance fire Firing flood Food Food/Agriculture food/health Footwear Foreigners Forests Fortune fraud Freight Friday Fruit Fuel FUNERAL Game Gangrape Gas Gold Governance Gulf states Hajj handicapped HANG Hate monger Health Heritage Hiousing History hobby Homes Honesty Hong Kong honour Hospital Hotel Human Being Human Rights Human Trafficking Hunting Immigration imports India Indian Election Industry Information Technology Infotainment int International internationl internet Invention Investment Islamophobia journalist judgement Judiciary justice Kashmir Kickbacks KIDNAPPING kiln labour Labourers Land Scam Landslide language Law Lawyers Lay Off Legislation Leisure Lifestyle lightning Liquor literature Litigation Loan loans Local Local Govt Manifesto Marriage Martyrs Mass Grave Massacre Matrimony Media Medical Medicines Memoirs Migrants Militants Military Mines Minorities MIRACLE mis mishap mishaps Missing people Misssing Monetary Money Laundering Monument Moon Mosque Mountaineer Murder Muslims n NAB Narcotics National Nature network Nuclear obituary occurred at a facility owned by the Ruiqi Daily Necessities Company. Officer Oil & Gas Oppotunity Organisations Orphans Overseas pakistani Paliament Parents Passengers PEMRA Petroleum Pilgrims pipeline PIR Police Politician POLITICS pollution Post poverty power President Ghani’s spokesman Sediq Sediqi criticised the development and said that the meeting couldn’t help the peace process. Priest Prison prisoner prisoners Probe project Properties Proscribed prosecution Protest Punishment Railway Real Estate Redcross Refinery Refugees Rejoinder Release Religion Religious Tourism relion Removal Rescue Reservoir Restrictions Reunion Revenue Riot Rivalry River Royal Satellite Saudi Arabia Scandal Science Seafood Security Sentence Services shemales ship Shipping Shooting Showbiz Sightseeing Sikh Community Singer Slavery smoking smuggling Snakebite Social Social Media Social Welfare Soldiers South Africa Space sports Spy strike Students Suicide Suicide Attack Superstition Taxation Technology telecom Terrorism The incident Theft Tobacco Tourism tourisn Tractors Trade Trade Union Traders Traditions Traffic Tragedy Training transgender Transport Travel trekkers Typhoon Hagibis Tyranny Umra United Kingdom United Nations United States Usury Vacancies Vegetable vehicle vendetaa Vengeance Violation Visa War Crime water Weapons weather wedding which is under investigation Wikileaks Wild fire Wildlife woman Women Women trafficking Workers Working class Writers youth
false
ltr
item
South Punjab News : Judges are ‘independent and yet dependent’: Justice Mansoor
Judges are ‘independent and yet dependent’: Justice Mansoor
they have even brought about a fundamental change in the Supreme Court bench by doing away with the custom of having an elevated floor for judges and a lower one for lawyers.
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Do37tK5hidc/XcaXZk6Kv_I/AAAAAAABPL4/GbS2wuQENWYFwMAlktsHt1O4Tj1geE3awCLcBGAsYHQ/s400/sc.jpg
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Do37tK5hidc/XcaXZk6Kv_I/AAAAAAABPL4/GbS2wuQENWYFwMAlktsHt1O4Tj1geE3awCLcBGAsYHQ/s72-c/sc.jpg
South Punjab News
http://www.southpunjabnews.com/2019/11/judges-are-independent-and-yet.html
http://www.southpunjabnews.com/
http://www.southpunjabnews.com/
http://www.southpunjabnews.com/2019/11/judges-are-independent-and-yet.html
true
949454145819430215
UTF-8
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy